12

I've never liked the taste of Guinness, on tap or from the can. But I have heard that it's much better tasting in Ireland, and the export one is completely different. Is there any truth to this, and if so, what are the differences?

6 Answers 6

7

Guinness can taste slightly different and have a different head based on where it's coming from. A big factor in this is how long the beer you're getting has been in the keg. People in Ireland drink Guinness a lot more than in the states, so kegs are replaced more frequently i.e. fresher beer. This is why if you go to a bar in Ireland and not a lot of people are drinking Guinness, you shouldn't get one.

Another possible reason you've heard this is that most people visit Dublin when they're in Ireland and have a pint at the Guinness store house. They ensure all the beer there is top of the line and it really is much better there than any other place I've had it.

4

There are a few questions here, so let me address them individually:

Guinness Draft, the "standard" Guinness is not always brewed in Ireland, so that may be one reason for a different taste in Ireland than in US. As gannolly commented, the age of the beer also affects the taste, as well as the cleanliness of the beerline (if the beer is on tap).

Guinness has a few beers, one of their biggest beers is a Foreign Extra Stout. This is brewed in various counties. This is a higher ABV, roastier beer. I think it has double the ABV of a "standard" Guinness.

One other important fact is emotions. If I am sitting in the Guinness Brewery, looking out over Dublin, drinking a fresh, perfectly poured Guinness, I am in a very happy place. This happiness will affect my overall experience of the beer. If you take that same keg, keep it cool and fly it overnight to the US and taste it there, it will still be good, but it will not be as good, because you are missing the experience. This said, the beer can also be just as good, because you remember the feeling of drinking that beer in Dublin.

Here are links to the various Guinness Breweries and the beers that are brewed there. http://www.ratebeer.com/brewers/st-jamess-gate-diageo/13/ http://www.ratebeer.com/brewers/guinness-cameroon/13088/ http://www.ratebeer.com/brewers/guinness-nigeria/3194/ http://www.ratebeer.com/brewers/guinness-ghana/5070/

1
  • That emotional aspect can't be overstated. Beer consumers aren't impartial observers.
    – Ernir
    May 4, 2016 at 15:07
3

In foreign countries, a particular brand of beer is often produced under a licence to a local brewer.

The accuracy with which these local brewers reproduce the original beer varies greatly.

For example, Australians noticed a change in the local Guinness when the local licensee changed from CUB to Lion recently: http://www.news.com.au/national/south-australia/lion-brews-the-first-guinness-in-south-australia-in-40-years/story-fndo4dzn-1226508692750

1

I just returned from a two week vacation in Ireland, Northern Ireland, Scotland and England. Guinness served in Ireland and Northern Ireland is very different than what you get in Guinness in the states. The Guinness in Ireland is silky, creamy and thick. Almost milkshake like. It is very delicious and after you have one there than here you will understand. I think it is a freshness issue.

0

I just returned from Ireland 2 weeks ago. I rode a motorcycle around most of the country for 8 days and spent a couple of days in Dublin. I drank the black stuff all over the country, including at the Storehouse. Here is my take: In the States, I only drink the nitro pub cans. I am not fond of any of the other packaged Guinness stouts sold here. I also find that draught Guinness Stout will vary more outside Ireland, mainly because of how it might be handled or poured. Bottom Line for me: The nitro pub cans are nearly identical to any pour you are are going to get in Ireland, except for this one small thing: I found Irish Guinness to be ever so slightly more minerally and even a tad salty than anywhere else.

-1

I do t believe this. I’ve had Guinness in draft in the UK and Europe and as far as I can tell, it’s the same as the Guinness I’ve had in USA. Yea freshness and proper storage and proper nitro mix makes a difference but if you have Guinness at a reputable pub it is the same. An Irish pub in New York or Chicago surely goes through a keg of Guinness as fast as any pub in Ireland.

1
  • 2
    I am unsure why you cannot tell the difference - they are worlds apart. They are made differently, by different brewers under licence. They have differing treatment for shipping purposes. Even kegs are different. Guinness in Dublin is even different to Guinness in London or Edinburgh - which is down to shipping, as they are brewed in the same brewery.
    – Rory Alsop
    Mar 17, 2023 at 11:30

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.